Costco vs Sam’s Club for Emerging Brands
- alexsteinbergmojo
- Jan 9
- 2 min read
For emerging brands looking to scale into warehouse retail, Costco and Sam’s Club often appear similar on the surface. Both operate large-format stores, sell in bulk, and attract value-driven shoppers.
However, the way each retailer evaluates brands, executes merchandising, and drives consumer behavior is fundamentally different. Understanding these differences is critical before choosing where to invest time, capital, and operational resources.
Costco operates with a highly curated, limited-assortment model that prioritizes quality, operational excellence, and long-term supplier relationships. Each product on the floor represents a deliberate buying decision by Costco’s merchandising team, which means brands are expected to perform immediately and consistently.
Costco is not built for experimentation. It favors proven products, scalable supply chains, and clear value propositions that resonate with its membership base. For emerging brands, this creates both a challenge and an opportunity. Entry standards are high, but successful performance can unlock massive volume, brand credibility, and repeat placement.
Sam’s Club, by contrast, operates with a broader assortment and a more traditional retail mindset. Brands may find slightly more flexibility during initial launches, especially when testing pricing, packaging, or regional demand. Sam’s Club shoppers tend to compare options more actively, which means merchandising, price
positioning, and promotional strategy play a larger role in conversion.
While this can offer emerging brands a softer entry point, it also means competition for attention is higher and brand differentiation must work harder.
Another key distinction lies in shopper psychology. Costco members enter the warehouse with strong trust in the retailer’s buying decisions. They assume products have been vetted for value and quality, which accelerates purchase behavior. Sam’s Club shoppers often behave more like traditional retail consumers, spending more time evaluating options and weighing alternatives. This difference directly impacts how brands should approach demos, packaging, and messaging. What works at Sam’s Club may feel slow or ineffective inside Costco.
Operational expectations also differ significantly. Costco places intense emphasis on supply chain reliability, packaging durability, and consistency across locations. Brands must be prepared to execute at scale with minimal disruption. Sam’s Club offers more room for iteration, but that flexibility often comes with less immediate upside in terms of velocity and brand prestige. Emerging brands must evaluate whether they are operationally ready for Costco’s standards or better positioned to refine their model within Sam’s Club first.
Ultimately, choosing between Costco and Sam’s Club is not about which retailer is better. It is about which retailer aligns with a brand’s current maturity, operational strength, and growth strategy. Costco rewards discipline, clarity, and performance, while Sam’s Club can support experimentation and broader assortment strategies. Brands that understand these differences position themselves for smarter launches and more sustainable growth.
If you want the best, give MOJO a call today.
Comments